Discover an unparalleled offering in the heart of historic Sag Harbor Village. Situated on an idyllic 0.63-acre corner lot, this meticulously restored Victorian delivers the ultimate Hamptons lifestyle: a luxuriously appointed main residence, a lofted studio, and resort-like grounds with a heated gunite pool. Just moments from Sag Harbor's iconic Main Street, and directly across from the serene Haven's Beach, this property perfectly blends timeless elegance with modern luxury. The main residence spans 4,500 +/- square feet of light-filled interiors, thoughtfully tailored for today's discerning homeowner. The 250 +/- sq. ft. wraparound porch, framed by lush gardens, welcomes you into a house that celebrates both the craftsmanship of Sag Harbor's maritime heritage and the sophistication of contemporary architecture. Inside, bright and open living quarters feature four bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms as well as five grand fireplaces. Inside the 2,279 +/- sq. ft. first floor, thoughtfully curated spaces balance grandeur and comfort. At the heart of the abode lies a chef's kitchen - a culinary haven complete with top-of-the-line appliances, dual dishwashers, a spacious walk-in pantry, and its own cozy fireplace. The formal dining room, graced by a large bay window, is ideal for hosting, while the sun-drenched living room, alluring den, and private office present a variety of enclaves to gather or repose. Two elegant staircases lead to the 1,660 +/- sq. ft. second floor, which exudes tranquility and refinement. The centerpiece upstairs is the primary suite, featuring a fireplace, spa-like en-suite bath, and walk-in closet. A spacious en-suite guest bedroom affords solitude, while two additional guest bedrooms share a well-appointed bathroom. A conveniently located laundry room rounds out the upper level, ensuring optimal ease for year-round living or extended stays. Set on the rear of the premises, the 980 +/- sq. ft. studio cottage provides an inviting reprieve for family or guests. This welcoming environment includes generous living chambers with a fireplace, a full bathroom, and a loft. Additionally, the 220 +/- sq. ft. garage grants practicality without compromising aesthetics, maintaining the compound's seamless design. Once outside, an exclusive sanctuary awaits: the impeccably manicured and fully irrigated grounds are planned for relaxation and entertainment. The 800 +/- sq. ft. freeform pool is bordered by a bluestone patio and surrounded by specimen trees for complete seclusion. Additional lawn areas create the perfect setting for al fresco dining or leisurely afternoons in the Hamptons sun. Located on one of the most coveted streets in Sag Harbor, just a short distance from renowned restaurants, boutique shops, marinas, and cultural landmarks, this parcel delivers the finest in both discretion and convenience. With 6,652 +/- sq. ft. of total living space and the tranquility of the nearby Cormaria Retreat as your neighbor, this quintessential captains home boasts an exceptional balance of serene escape and vibrant village life. Properties of this size, scale, and quality are exceedingly rare in Sag Harbor Village. 98 Bay Street is not just an ordinary domicile - it's a legacy. Don't miss the opportunity to make this remarkable estate your own.

This is an Active listing.

Broker Office Phone Number: 631-537-5454

Copyright © 2025My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.