Gallery
Hybrid
Map
Skip to main content
CityHomes: Homes For Sale and Homes for Rent
Staten Island Tottenville
global settings
Tottenville
(0)Status
(0)Price
(0)Bedrooms
(0)Bathrooms
(0)Type
(0)Square Feet
(0)Amenities
(0)Acres
(0)Virtual
(0)Other
(0)Keyword

51 Homes for Sale in Tottenville

12345

Staten Island Homes For Sale

  • Tottenville Single Family Home for Sale
  • Tottenville Multi-Family Home for Sale
  • Tottenville Townhouse for Sale
  • Tottenville Land for Sale
  • Tottenville Condominium for Sale
Google Maps Static Image
3. 133 Fisher Avenue
1. 133 Fisher Avenue
2. 133 Fisher Avenue
1 of 3
new listing 5 days ago
Tottenville
133 Fisher Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
4 Bd1 Ba1,885 SF
Single Family Home
$799,000
$424 SF
Listing by: AMR Properties
Listed:7/21/2025$799,000
datePricevariancetype
7/21/2025$799,000--Listed
33. 137 Butler Avenue
1. 137 Butler Avenue
2. 137 Butler Avenue
1 of 33
new listing 7 days ago
Tottenville
137 Butler Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
6 Bd2 Ba
Single Family Home
$1,288,000
Listing by: DiTommaso Real Estate
Listed:7/19/2025$1,288,000
datePricevariancetype
7/19/2025$1,288,000--Listed
12. 30 Paradise Place
1. 30 Paradise Place
2. 30 Paradise Place
1 of 12
new listing 9 days ago
Tottenville
30 Paradise Place
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
5 Bd2 Ba3,500 SF
Single Family Home
$1,859,000
$531 SF
Listing by: DiTommaso Real Estate
Listed:7/17/2025$1,859,000
datePricevariancetype
7/17/2025$1,859,000--Listed
20. 22 Murray Street
1. 22 Murray Street
2. 22 Murray Street
1 of 20
Reduced 07-15-25
Tottenville
22 Murray Street
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10309
3 Bd1 Ba1,400 SF
Single Family Home
$729,000
$521 SF
Listing by: J Milo Real Estate
decreased:7/15/2025$729,000(1.35%)
datePricevariancetype
7/15/2025$729,000-1.35%decreased
5/29/2025$739,000--Listed
49. 43 Lerer Lane
1. 43 Lerer Lane
2. 43 Lerer Lane
1 of 49
new listing 11 days ago
Tottenville
43 Lerer Lane
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
4 Bd3 Ba2,500 SF
Multi-Family Home
$1,149,000
$460 SF
Listing by: EXP Realty
decreased:4/16/2025$1,149,000(4.24%)
datePricevariancetype
4/16/2025$1,149,000-4.24%decreased
2/1/2025$1,199,900--Listed
7. 233 Fisher Avenue
1. 233 Fisher Avenue
2. 233 Fisher Avenue
1 of 7
new listing 14 days ago
Tottenville
233 Fisher Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
4 Bd2 Ba1,600 SF
Multi-Family Home
$999,000
$624 SF
Listing by: R. Della Realty Corp.
Listed:7/12/2025$999,000
datePricevariancetype
7/12/2025$999,000--Listed
25. 162 Bentley Street
1. 162 Bentley Street
2. 162 Bentley Street
1 of 25
new listing 15 days ago
Tottenville
162 Bentley Street
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
4 Bd1 Ba1,768 SF
Single Family Home
$988,000
$559 SF
Listing by: Tiger Realty
Listed:7/11/2025$988,000
datePricevariancetype
7/11/2025$988,000--Listed
3. 320 Sprague Avenue
1. 320 Sprague Avenue
2. 320 Sprague Avenue
1 of 3
new listing 15 days ago
Tottenville
320 Sprague Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
3 Bd1 Ba1,120 SF
Single Family Home
$1,395,000
$1,246 SF
Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty
Listed:7/11/2025$1,395,000
datePricevariancetype
7/11/2025$1,395,000--Listed
42. 254 Wood Avenue
1. 254 Wood Avenue
2. 254 Wood Avenue
1 of 42
Tottenville
254 Wood Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
5 Bd3 Ba2,291 SF
Multi-Family Home
$1,349,999
$589 SF
Listing by: Connie Profaci Realty
Listed:7/7/2025$1,349,999
datePricevariancetype
7/7/2025$1,349,999--Listed
49. 90 Giegerich Avenue
1. 90 Giegerich Avenue
2. 90 Giegerich Avenue
1 of 49
Reduced 07-15-25
Tottenville
90 Giegerich Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
5 Bd4 Ba5,760 SF
Single Family Home
$2,199,999
$382 SF
Listing by: J Milo Real Estate
decreased:7/15/2025$2,199,999(4.35%)
datePricevariancetype
7/15/2025$2,199,999-4.35%decreased
5/27/2025$2,299,999-4.17%decreased
3/7/2025$2,399,999+99941.64%increased
3/7/2025$2,399--Listed
1. 215 Clearmont Avenue
new listing 26 days ago
Tottenville
215 Clearmont Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
Land
$2,899,999
Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty
Listed:6/30/2025$2,899,999
datePricevariancetype
6/30/2025$2,899,999--Listed
34. 217-219 Fisher Avenue
1. 217-219 Fisher Avenue
2. 217-219 Fisher Avenue
1 of 34
Contract 07-23-25
Tottenville
217-219 Fisher Avenue
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10307
6 Bd3 Ba2,998 SF
Multi-Family Home
$949,999
$317 SF
Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty
Contract:7/23/2025$949,999
datePricevariancetype
7/23/2025$949,999--Contract
6/26/2025$949,999--Listed
Open House7-26-25|1:00 PM - 3:00 PM
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Agent Products
  • Broker Products
  • Display Your Listings
  • Feedback
  • Sitemap
  • Agent Log In
    • Sales
      • United States Homes for Sale
      • Atlanta Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Austin Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Boston Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Chicago Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Dallas Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Las Vegas Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Miami Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • New York City Apartments for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Philadelphia Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Washington DC Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
    • Rentals
      • United States Homes For Rent
      • Atlanta Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Austin Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Boston Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Chicago Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Dallas Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Las Vegas Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Miami Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • New York City Apartments for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Philadelphia Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Washington DC Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
    • Buildings
      • All Buildings
      • New Home Communities
        • Single Family
        • Condo/Townhouse
      • Adult/Senior Communities
    • Locations
    • Agents
      • United States Real Estate Agents
      • Atlanta Real Estate Agents
      • Austin Real Estate Agents
      • Boston Real Estate Agents
      • Chicago Real Estate Agents
      • Dallas Real Estate Agents
      • Las Vegas Real Estate Agents
      • Miami Real Estate Agents
      • New York Real Estate Agents
      • Philadelphia Real Estate Agents
      • Washington DC Real Estate Agents
    • City Sites
      • CityHomes
      • Atlanta
      • Austin
      • Boston
      • Chicago
      • Dallas
      • Las Vegas
      • Miami
      • New York City
      • Philadelphia
      • Washington DC
    • Products
      • Agents
      • Brokers
      • Franchises
      • Display Your Listings