51 Homes for Sale in Tottenville

5 Haywood Street

6 Bd4 Ba5,500 SF

Single Family Home

$1,900,000

$345 SF

Listing by: BHGRE Safari Realty

decreased:7/15/2025$1,900,000(13.60%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/15/2025	$1,900,000	-13.60%	decreased
5/23/2025	$2,199,000	--	Listed

1 of 20

Reduced 07-26-25

5448 Arthur Kill Road

8 Bd1 Ba4,508 SF

Multi-Family Home

$1,350,000

$299 SF

Listing by: Triolo Realty Group, Inc.

decreased:7/26/2025$1,350,000(9.94%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/26/2025	$1,350,000	-9.94%	decreased
6/27/2025	$1,499,000	-11.77%	decreased
5/20/2025	$1,699,000	--	Listed

1 of 39

Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10306

4 Bd1 Ba2,033 SF

Single Family Home

$888,000

$437 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

Listed:5/20/2025$888,000

date	Price	variance	type
5/20/2025	$888,000	--	Listed

1 of 44

Contract 06-06-25

4 Bd1 Ba2,033 SF

Single Family Home

$855,000

$421 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

Contract:6/6/2025$855,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/6/2025	$855,000	--	Contract
6/2/2025	$855,000	-3.72%	decreased
5/20/2025	$888,000	--	Listed

1 of 47

261 Chelsea Street

2 Ba4,286 SF

Single Family Home

$1,999,999

$467 SF

Listing by: J Milo Real Estate

Listed:5/8/2025$1,999,999

date	Price	variance	type
5/8/2025	$1,999,999	--	Listed

1 of 17

230 Bedell Avenue

2 Bd1 Ba700 SF

Single Family Home

$799,000

$1,141 SF

Listing by: Remax Edge

Listed:5/13/2025$799,000

date	Price	variance	type
5/13/2025	$799,000	--	Listed

1 of 49

Reduced 07-23-25

30 Aviva Court

4 Bd1 Ba7,313 SF

Single Family Home

$3,977,000

$544 SF

Listing by: Keller Williams Realty Staten Island

1 of 27

64 Ottavio Promenade

4 Bd1 Ba4,914 SF

Single Family Home

$2,949,000

$600 SF

Listing by: Keller Williams Realty Staten Island

decreased:7/21/2025$2,949,000(1.67%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/21/2025	$2,949,000	-1.67%	decreased
5/9/2025	$2,999,000	-6.25%	decreased
12/11/2024	$3,199,000	-1.57%	decreased
10/25/2024	$3,250,000	--	Listed

1 of 30

Contract 06-14-25

183 Brighton Street

5 Bd4 Ba2,226 SF

Multi-Family Home

$1,299,900

$584 SF

Listing by: JM Properties

Contract:6/14/2025$1,299,900

date	Price	variance	type
6/14/2025	$1,299,900	--	Contract
5/23/2025	$1,299,900	-4.41%	decreased
5/6/2025	$1,359,900	--	Listed

1 of 20

Reduced 06-21-25

241 Loretto Street

2 Bd1 Ba992 SF

Residential

$549,000

$553 SF

Listing by: AMR Properties

decreased:6/21/2025$549,000(1.08%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/21/2025	$549,000	-1.08%	decreased
5/22/2025	$555,000	-4.15%	decreased
4/30/2025	$579,000	--	Listed

1 of 49

147 Wood Avenue

3 Bd2 Ba1,872 SF

Single Family Home

$948,000

$506 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

decreased:5/27/2025$948,000(4.05%)

date	Price	variance	type
5/27/2025	$948,000	-4.05%	decreased
4/29/2025	$988,000	--	Listed

1 of 46

14 Ottavio Promenade

4 Bd4 Ba10,200 SF

Single Family Home

$3,100,000

$304 SF

Listing by: JM Properties

increased:4/30/2025$3,100,000(0.04%)

date	Price	variance	type
4/30/2025	$3,100,000	+0.04%	increased
1/1/2025	$3,098,888	--	Listed

1 of 50

Reduced 07-15-25

5 Haywood Street

6 Bd4 Ba5,500 SF

Single Family Home

$1,900,000

$345 SF

Listing by: BHGRE Safari Realty

decreased:7/15/2025$1,900,000(13.60%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/15/2025	$1,900,000	-13.60%	decreased
5/23/2025	$2,199,000	--	Listed

1 of 20

Reduced 07-26-25

5448 Arthur Kill Road

8 Bd1 Ba4,508 SF

Multi-Family Home

$1,350,000

$299 SF

Listing by: Triolo Realty Group, Inc.

decreased:7/26/2025$1,350,000(9.94%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/26/2025	$1,350,000	-9.94%	decreased
6/27/2025	$1,499,000	-11.77%	decreased
5/20/2025	$1,699,000	--	Listed

1 of 39

Tottenville, Staten Island, NY 10306

4 Bd1 Ba2,033 SF

Single Family Home

$888,000

$437 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

Listed:5/20/2025$888,000

date	Price	variance	type
5/20/2025	$888,000	--	Listed

1 of 44

Contract 06-06-25

4 Bd1 Ba2,033 SF

Single Family Home

$855,000

$421 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

Contract:6/6/2025$855,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/6/2025	$855,000	--	Contract
6/2/2025	$855,000	-3.72%	decreased
5/20/2025	$888,000	--	Listed

1 of 47

261 Chelsea Street

2 Ba4,286 SF

Single Family Home

$1,999,999

$467 SF

Listing by: J Milo Real Estate

Listed:5/8/2025$1,999,999

date	Price	variance	type
5/8/2025	$1,999,999	--	Listed

1 of 17

230 Bedell Avenue

2 Bd1 Ba700 SF

Single Family Home

$799,000

$1,141 SF

Listing by: Remax Edge

Listed:5/13/2025$799,000

date	Price	variance	type
5/13/2025	$799,000	--	Listed

1 of 49

Reduced 07-23-25

30 Aviva Court

4 Bd1 Ba7,313 SF

Single Family Home

$3,977,000

$544 SF

Listing by: Keller Williams Realty Staten Island

1 of 27

64 Ottavio Promenade

4 Bd1 Ba4,914 SF

Single Family Home

$2,949,000

$600 SF

Listing by: Keller Williams Realty Staten Island

decreased:7/21/2025$2,949,000(1.67%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/21/2025	$2,949,000	-1.67%	decreased
5/9/2025	$2,999,000	-6.25%	decreased
12/11/2024	$3,199,000	-1.57%	decreased
10/25/2024	$3,250,000	--	Listed

1 of 30

Contract 06-14-25

183 Brighton Street

5 Bd4 Ba2,226 SF

Multi-Family Home

$1,299,900

$584 SF

Listing by: JM Properties

Contract:6/14/2025$1,299,900

date	Price	variance	type
6/14/2025	$1,299,900	--	Contract
5/23/2025	$1,299,900	-4.41%	decreased
5/6/2025	$1,359,900	--	Listed

1 of 20

Reduced 06-21-25

241 Loretto Street

2 Bd1 Ba992 SF

Residential

$549,000

$553 SF

Listing by: AMR Properties

decreased:6/21/2025$549,000(1.08%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/21/2025	$549,000	-1.08%	decreased
5/22/2025	$555,000	-4.15%	decreased
4/30/2025	$579,000	--	Listed

1 of 49

147 Wood Avenue

3 Bd2 Ba1,872 SF

Single Family Home

$948,000

$506 SF

Listing by: Robert Defalco Realty

decreased:5/27/2025$948,000(4.05%)

date	Price	variance	type
5/27/2025	$948,000	-4.05%	decreased
4/29/2025	$988,000	--	Listed

1 of 46

14 Ottavio Promenade