Gallery
Hybrid
Map
Skip to main content
CityHomes: Homes For Sale and Homes for Rent
Windley Key
global settings
Windley Key
(0)Status
(0)Price
(0)Bedrooms
(0)Bathrooms
(0)Type
(0)Square Feet
(0)Amenities
(0)Acres
(0)Virtual
(0)Other
(0)Keyword

8 Homes for Sale in Windley Key

Cities near Windley Key

  • Homestead Homes For Sale
  • Key Largo Homes For Sale
  • Cutler Bay Homes For Sale
  • Florida City Homes For Sale
  • Marathon Homes For Sale
  • Palmetto Bay Homes For Sale
  • Plantation Key Homes For Sale
  • Islamorada Homes For Sale
  • Key Colony Homes For Sale
  • Duck Key Homes For Sale
  • Tavernier Homes For Sale
  • Long Key Homes For Sale
  • Key Colony Beach Homes For Sale
  • Goulds Homes For Sale
  • No Name Key Homes For Sale
  • Perrine Homes For Sale
  • Conch Key Homes For Sale
  • view more nearby cities

Windley Key Homes For Sale

  • Windley Key Single Family Home for Sale
  • Windley Key Townhouse for Sale
  • Windley Key Land for Sale

zip near Windley Key

  • 33033 Homes For Sale
  • 33032 Homes For Sale
  • 33037 Homes For Sale
  • 33035 Homes For Sale
  • 33030 Homes For Sale
  • 33050 Homes For Sale
  • 33177 Homes For Sale
  • 33031 Homes For Sale
  • 33196 Homes For Sale
  • 33170 Homes For Sale
  • 33187 Homes For Sale
  • view more zips
Google Maps Static Image
50. 84745 Old Highway
1. 84745 Old Highway
2. 84745 Old Highway
1 of 50
new listing 1 days ago
Windley Key
84745 Old Highway
Windley Key, FL 33036
3 Bd3 Ba1,680 SF
Townhouse
$1,599,000
$952 SF
Listing by: American Caribbean Real Estate, Christie's International Real Estate
decreased:8/2/2025$1,599,000(3.03%)
datePricevariancetype
8/2/2025$1,599,000-3.03%decreased
2/17/2025$1,649,000--
2/17/2025$1,649,000-3.00%decreased
1/30/2025$1,700,000-2.86%decreased
12/26/2024$1,750,100+0.01%increased
9/25/2024$1,750,000--Listed
50. 84745 Old Highway
1. 84745 Old Highway
2. 84745 Old Highway
1 of 50
new listing 1 days ago
Windley Key
84745 Old Highway
Windley Key, FL 33036
3 Bd3 Ba1,680 SF
Townhouse
$1,499,000
$892 SF
Listing by: American Caribbean Real Estate, Christie's International Real Estate
decreased:8/2/2025$1,499,000(6.25%)
datePricevariancetype
8/2/2025$1,499,000-6.25%decreased
2/17/2025$1,599,000-5.67%decreased
12/26/2024$1,695,100+0.01%increased
10/20/2024$1,695,000-3.14%decreased
9/29/2024$1,750,000--Listed
47. 84961 Old Highway
1. 84961 Old Highway
2. 84961 Old Highway
1 of 47
new listing 13 days ago
Windley Key
84961 Old Highway
Windley Key, FL 33036
2 Bd2 Ba946 SF
Single Family Home
$1,590,000
$1,681 SF
Listing by: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Keys Real Estate - Islamorada
Listed:8/2/2025$1,590,000
datePricevariancetype
8/2/2025$1,590,000--Listed
37. 110 Anglers Way
1. 110 Anglers Way
2. 110 Anglers Way
1 of 37
new listing 14 days ago
Windley Key
110 Anglers Way
Windley Key, FL 33036
2 Bd2 Ba1,522 SF
Single Family Home
$1,265,000
$831 SF
Listing by: BHHS Florida Realty
Listed:7/25/2025$1,265,000
datePricevariancetype
7/25/2025$1,265,000--Listed
9. 104 Anglers Way
1. 104 Anglers Way
2. 104 Anglers Way
1 of 9
Reduced 08-11-25
Windley Key
104 Anglers Way
Windley Key, FL 33036
2 Bd2 Ba1,376 SF
Single Family Home
$1,299,999
$945 SF
Listing by: CASA MIAMI REAL ESTATE
decreased:8/11/2025$1,299,999(3.70%)
datePricevariancetype
8/11/2025$1,299,999-3.70%decreased
7/7/2025$1,350,000--Listed
10. 85321 Old Highway
1. 85321 Old Highway
2. 85321 Old Highway
1 of 10
Windley Key
85321 Old Highway
Windley Key, FL 33036
Land
$2,495,000
Listing by: Ocean Sotheby's International Realty
decreased:5/15/2025$2,495,000(7.59%)
datePricevariancetype
5/15/2025$2,495,000-7.59%decreased
2/28/2025$2,700,000--Listed
50. 84745 Old Highway
1. 84745 Old Highway
2. 84745 Old Highway
1 of 50
Windley Key
84745 Old Highway
Windley Key, FL 33036
3 Bd3 Ba1,680 SF
Townhouse
$1,699,000
$1,011 SF
Listing by: American Caribbean Real Estate, Christie's International Real Estate
decreased:8/2/2025$1,699,000(2.86%)
datePricevariancetype
8/2/2025$1,699,000-2.86%decreased
2/17/2025$1,749,000-2.56%decreased
12/26/2024$1,795,000-0.28%decreased
11/16/2024$1,800,000-5.26%decreased
9/23/2024$1,900,000--Listed
36. 102 Anglers Way
1. 102 Anglers Way
2. 102 Anglers Way
1 of 36
Windley Key
102 Anglers Way
Windley Key, FL 33036
2 Bd2 Ba1,376 SF
Single Family Home
$1,150,000
$836 SF
Listing by: BHHS Florida Realty
decreased:7/26/2025$1,150,000(4.17%)
datePricevariancetype
7/26/2025$1,150,000-4.17%decreased
1/22/2025$1,199,999--Listed
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Agent Products
  • Broker Products
  • Display Your Listings
  • Feedback
  • Sitemap
  • Agent Log In
    • Sales
      • United States Homes for Sale
      • Atlanta Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Austin Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Boston Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Chicago Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Dallas Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Las Vegas Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Miami Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • New York City Apartments for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Philadelphia Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
      • Washington DC Homes for Sale
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • Price Reduced
        • New Listings
    • Rentals
      • United States Homes For Rent
      • Atlanta Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Austin Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Boston Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Chicago Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Dallas Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Las Vegas Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Miami Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • New York City Apartments for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Philadelphia Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
      • Washington DC Homes for Rent
        • All Listings
        • Open Houses
        • New Listings
    • Buildings
      • All Buildings
      • New Home Communities
        • Single Family
        • Condo/Townhouse
      • Adult/Senior Communities
    • Locations
    • Agents
      • United States Real Estate Agents
      • Atlanta Real Estate Agents
      • Austin Real Estate Agents
      • Boston Real Estate Agents
      • Chicago Real Estate Agents
      • Dallas Real Estate Agents
      • Las Vegas Real Estate Agents
      • Miami Real Estate Agents
      • New York Real Estate Agents
      • Philadelphia Real Estate Agents
      • Washington DC Real Estate Agents
    • City Sites
      • CityHomes
      • Atlanta
      • Austin
      • Boston
      • Chicago
      • Dallas
      • Las Vegas
      • Miami
      • New York City
      • Philadelphia
      • Washington DC
    • Products
      • Agents
      • Brokers
      • Franchises
      • Display Your Listings